Sleep Hygiene Is Great. I'd Prefer Actual Sleep.

I have a confession to make, and it's one that probably deserves to be reported to the psychiatric provider licensing authorities.

I am terrible at sleep hygiene.

This is not exactly breaking news. In my recent "Meet Aimee" Instagram post, I was asked what advice I routinely give my patients but am spectacularly bad at following myself. Without hesitation, I admitted that it was sleep hygiene. Publicly. On the internet. Where my patients can see it. Not because I don't understand it. I understand it beautifully. I can deliver an excellent, evidence-based lecture on the importance of consistent sleep schedules, limiting evening screen time, and creating an environment conducive to sleep. I am practically a sleep hygiene evangelist. And then, at 11:47 p.m., I am in bed, illuminated by the soft glow of my phone, reading an article about something I absolutely did not need to know before morning.

The hypocrisy is not lost on me. Apparently, neither is the phone.

But here's the thing: even if I followed every single recommendation I give my patients, that wouldn't necessarily guarantee me a good night's sleep. Because insomnia is more complicated than putting down your phone, buying some blackout curtains, and pretending chamomile tea is going to fix whatever fresh hell your nervous system has decided to unleash at bedtime.

And that's what I want to talk about.

First, Can We Stop Pretending Sleep Is a Personal Achievement?

Somewhere along the way, sleep became another thing we're supposed to optimize. We have sleep trackers, sleep scores, sleep supplements, sleep podcasts, sleep routines, and people on Instagram who apparently begin preparing for bed shortly after lunch. And if we're still not sleeping? Well, clearly we're doing something wrong. Except sleep isn't a performance. It's a biological process governed by an extraordinarily complicated interaction between circadian rhythms, sleep pressure, hormones, neurotransmitters, physical health, and the nervous system's assessment of whether it's safe to stop paying attention to everything. You cannot simply decide to sleep through sheer determination. In fact, trying harder is often precisely what makes insomnia worse. Which is particularly insulting when you're exhausted. Imagine if the harder you tried to eat lunch, the less capable you became of swallowing a sandwich. We'd recognize that as a problem immediately. But when it comes to sleep, we keep telling people to relax harder.

Your Brain Has Apparently Scheduled a Staff Meeting for 3 A.M.

One of the most frustrating features of insomnia is how quickly the bed can become a place of dread. Initially, you might have trouble sleeping because of something entirely reasonable: a stressful period at work, a new baby, hormonal changes, illness, grief, or a medication adjustment. A few bad nights follow. Then you start worrying about having another bad night. And suddenly, bedtime has become an event. You calculate how many hours you could theoretically get if you fell asleep immediately. You check the clock. You think about tomorrow's responsibilities. You notice your heart beating. You wonder whether you're going to be functional enough to work, parent, drive, or remember your own zip code. Your brain, recognizing that you appear concerned about something, helpfully increases its vigilance.

Congratulations. You are now too alert to sleep because you're worried about not sleeping.

This is called conditioned arousal, and it's an important part of how short-term sleep difficulties can develop into chronic insomnia. Over time, the bedroom itself can become associated with frustration, wakefulness, and anxiety rather than sleep. Your mattress hasn't done anything wrong. Your nervous system has simply developed a deeply unfortunate association.

Sleep Hygiene Is Useful. It Is Not a Treatment Plan.

Let's give sleep hygiene the credit it deserves. Consistent wake times, appropriate light exposure, a comfortable sleeping environment, and reasonable caffeine habits can all support healthy sleep. And yes, putting down your phone is generally a good idea. I say this with the authority of someone who will probably ignore her own advice tonight. But here's the distinction that matters: sleep hygiene alone is not an adequate treatment for chronic insomnia. For persistent insomnia, the recommended first-line treatment is cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, or CBT-I. Not simply cognitive behavioral therapy with a few bedtime suggestions thrown in. CBT-I is a structured, evidence-based treatment that helps retrain the relationship between sleep, wakefulness, the bedroom, and the anxiety that can develop around all three. And it has substantially better evidence for lasting improvement than another beautifully packaged bottle of something called Quantum Moon Goddess™ Cortisol Reset & Nervous System Recalibration Peptide.

I made that name up. If you're already reaching for your credit card, we need to have a separate conversation.

So What Does CBT-I Actually Do?

CBT-I typically combines several approaches, and some of them are surprisingly counterintuitive. One is stimulus control, which aims to rebuild the association between your bed and sleep. If you're lying awake becoming increasingly frustrated, the goal isn't to remain there for two hours negotiating with your nervous system. Instead, you get up, do something quiet in dim light, and return when you're sleepy. Another is sleep restriction therapy, sometimes called sleep compression when introduced more gradually. This involves adjusting the amount of time spent in bed to better match the amount of time you're actually sleeping, then expanding that window as sleep becomes more consolidated.

Yes, sometimes the treatment for insomnia initially involves spending less time in bed. I understand how offensive that sounds. These techniques are paired with strategies that address unhelpful beliefs about sleep, reduce sleep-related anxiety, and establish more consistent sleep-wake patterns. Importantly, sleep restriction isn't appropriate for everyone without modification. People with bipolar disorder, seizure disorders, significant daytime sleepiness, or certain other medical or safety concerns need individualized guidance. This is one reason I prefer people work with a clinician trained in CBT-I rather than attempting an aggressive sleep-restriction program on their own. The goal isn't to punish you for being awake. It's to help your brain remember how to sleep without turning bedtime into a competitive sport.

Women Have Some Additional Reasons to Be Awake

As if the basic mechanics of insomnia weren't complicated enough, women get to contend with a few additional variables. Hormonal fluctuations across the menstrual cycle, pregnancy, postpartum period, perimenopause, and menopause can affect sleep quality and continuity. During perimenopause, for example, changes in reproductive hormones may contribute to sleep disruption, while night sweats and hot flashes can make staying asleep particularly difficult. But hormones aren't the whole story. Women also experience higher rates of insomnia than men, and sleep difficulties frequently intersect with anxiety, depression, chronic pain, caregiving responsibilities, and the mental labor of managing everyone else's existence.

Sometimes the problem isn't that your brain won't shut off. It's that nobody has stopped asking it to do things. And sometimes several of these factors are happening simultaneously. A woman might be experiencing perimenopausal night sweats, an anxiety disorder, an inconsistent work schedule, and a partner who snores like a malfunctioning agricultural machine. Telling her to try a warm bath is not a comprehensive treatment strategy.

Not Every Sleep Problem Is Insomnia

This is where a good clinical assessment becomes especially important. Difficulty falling asleep, waking repeatedly, waking too early, and feeling unrefreshed despite adequate time in bed can have different causes. Some people have a delayed circadian rhythm, meaning their natural sleep timing is shifted later than their responsibilities allow. Others have restless legs syndrome, sleep apnea, medication-related sleep disruption, chronic pain, or an underlying mood disorder. Sleep apnea, in particular, deserves attention in women. It doesn't always present as the stereotypical loudly snoring man who falls asleep in his recliner. Women may report insomnia, fatigue, headaches, or mood symptoms, and their sleep-disordered breathing can go unrecognized. And if you're waking up exhausted despite spending eight or nine hours in bed, that's a different clinical question from being unable to fall asleep in the first place. These distinctions matter because treating the wrong problem can mean months or years of frustration. Sometimes the answer isn't better sleep hygiene. Sometimes it's a sleep study, a medication review, treatment of an underlying condition, or a different approach entirely.

And What About Sleeping Pills?

Ah, yes. The part where everyone gets nervous.

Sleep medications have become a strangely moralized subject. Some people view them as an absolute last resort, while others have been prescribed the same sedating medication for years without anyone revisiting whether it's still the best option.

Neither extreme is particularly helpful.

There are legitimate situations in which medication can be appropriate, especially when insomnia is severe, causing meaningful impairment, or occurring alongside another condition that requires treatment. But medications are not interchangeable simply because they make someone sleepy. Traditional hypnotics, dual orexin receptor antagonists, low-dose doxepin, and other agents have different mechanisms, benefits, and risks. The best choice depends on the type of insomnia, medical history, other medications, age, and individual circumstances. And we need to talk about a particularly common practice: prescribing medications primarily because sedation happens to be one of their side effects. An antihistamine, an antidepressant, and an antipsychotic may all cause drowsiness. That doesn't mean they are equally appropriate treatments for insomnia. Some carry meaningful metabolic, anticholinergic, cardiovascular, or next-day cognitive risks. Making someone unconscious is not necessarily the same thing as restoring healthy sleep. I don't believe patients should feel ashamed for needing medication. I also don't believe medication should be the only tool we offer them.

The goal is better sleep, better functioning, and a treatment plan that makes sense for the actual person sitting in front of me.

Please Stop Trying to Win at Sleeping

One of the most useful things we can do for insomnia is change the way we think about it. A bad night doesn't mean tomorrow is ruined. You don't have to monitor every minute of sleep to know whether you're functioning. And you certainly don't need to turn your wearable sleep score into a daily referendum on your personal worth. Sleep trackers can provide interesting information, but they aren't diagnostic instruments, and for some people they increase anxiety about sleep rather than reduce it. There's even a term for becoming excessively preoccupied with achieving perfect sleep data: orthosomnia. Because apparently we needed another thing to be anxious about. If you're lying awake, the goal is not to force sleep to happen. It's to reduce the struggle surrounding wakefulness, address the factors that are keeping your nervous system activated, and give your body's natural sleep mechanisms a better opportunity to do their job. Sometimes that also means recognizing that you have spent so long worrying about sleep that you've forgotten what it feels like not to think about it.

You Deserve More Than Another Lecture About Your Phone

I will continue recommending healthy sleep habits to my patients. I will continue encouraging consistent wake times, appropriate light exposure, and a bedroom that isn't doubling as a home office, entertainment center, and headquarters for existential dread. But I also want women to know that if they've tried all the usual advice and they're still not sleeping, it doesn't mean they're lazy, undisciplined, or somehow failing at being adults. Chronic insomnia is a treatable condition. It deserves an actual assessment and an actual treatment plan.

At Encompass, that means looking beyond the obvious. We consider mental health, hormones, medications, physical symptoms, sleep patterns, and the circumstances of your life. Sometimes that means treating an underlying psychiatric condition. Sometimes it means helping you access CBT-I or appropriate sleep testing. Sometimes medication is part of the conversation.

And sometimes the most helpful thing I can say is that you don't need another person telling you to put down your phone.

Although, in fairness, I probably do put down my phone.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I have an article to finish reading on my phone.

It's 11:47 p.m.

Next
Next

I Just Had a Few Complaints About Women's Healthcare. Things Escalated.